The Tiananmen Square Massacre and the Perils of Historical Erasure

Christian Baghai
3 min readOct 21, 2023

--

The annals of history are littered with instances of violence, suppression, and horrors that are unimaginable to most of us. And while we cannot undo the past, we have a moral obligation to remember it, to understand it, so that it serves as a guidepost, warning us about the slippery slopes that lead to the degradation of human values. But what happens when a government decides that some events, especially those that expose the ugly face of its own regime, must be wiped clean from collective memory? What happens is a travesty that compounds the original crime — this is what’s happening with the Chinese government’s sustained campaign to erase the Tiananmen Square massacre from history.

On June 4, 1989, Beijing’s Tiananmen Square became the epicenter of a horrifying crackdown against pro-democracy protesters. The exact count of how many people died under the trampling boots and rattling gunfire of the military is not known, but estimates range from hundreds to possibly thousands. Let’s be clear: these weren’t “counter-revolutionaries” jeopardizing national security, as the Chinese government would have you believe. These were students, intellectuals, and everyday citizens crying out for democracy, for the fundamental human rights that most of us take for granted. Their cries were met with bullets, their peaceful gatherings turned into bloodbaths.

In a move that’s equally disturbing, though far more insidious, the Chinese authorities have embarked on a campaign to distort the narrative surrounding the events of that fateful summer. They have deployed a variety of tactics to whitewash this dark chapter:

Rebranding the Victims: By labeling the protesters as counter-revolutionaries who threatened national stability, the government not only distorts history but also insults the memory of those who perished. Soldiers who were part of the crackdown are hailed as saviors — this is an appalling inversion of victim and perpetrator.

Suppressing Public Commemoration: Public gatherings or memorials that aim to honor the victims are not just discouraged, they’re outlawed. People who dare to defy this ban are subjected to arrests and harassment, further emphasizing the state’s control over individual liberties.

Information Blackout: Books, websites, and any form of media that mention the massacre are either removed or blocked. This is 21st-century book-burning, happening right under our noses.

International Pressure: The arm of censorship extends beyond mainland China, with the government pressuring other countries to remove or relocate memorials commemorating the event. The removal of the Pillar of Shame statue in Hong Kong is a chilling example of this.

Denial and Obfuscation: The Chinese government has consistently downplayed the severity of the massacre, refusing to release any official records. This veil of secrecy adds insult to injury, denying justice and closure to the families of the victims.

All these maneuvers have a singular aim: to secure the regime’s grip on power by controlling the narrative, curating a version of history that serves its interests. But here’s the thing — memory, collective or individual, has a way of defying erasure. People in China and around the globe still remember, still mourn, and still demand justice for the lives lost.

--

--