The Deep Roots of Political Ideology and Its Impact on Reasoning

6 min readJan 9, 2025

You ever notice how political ideology screws up your ability to think straight? It’s like we’ve collectively decided to wear blinders while running full speed toward a wall. Let’s dig into why that is, and, spoiler alert, it’s not because humans are inherently reasonable. No, it’s because we’re tribal, emotional, and just a little bit stupid. And guess what? That’s evolution’s fault.

The Evolutionary Basis of Ideological Thinking

1. Group Survival and Cohesion

Back in the caveman days, the only ideology was: “Don’t get eaten.” Simple, right? But to pull it off, you had to stick with your tribe. Shared norms kept the group alive. If someone decided to go rogue and start a “lions are just misunderstood” movement, guess what? They got eaten. Problem solved.

Now we’re stuck with the mental wiring that tells us to cling to whatever our group thinks, even if it’s batshit crazy. It’s why people defend their political beliefs like they’re fighting off a saber-toothed tiger — because deep down, our brains still think it’s life or death.

2. Adaptive Heuristics

Our ancestors didn’t have time for nuanced debates. They needed quick answers, so the brain cooked up heuristics — those mental shortcuts that say, “us good, them bad.” Back then, it was about staying alive. Now? It’s about staying self-righteous on Twitter. Same wiring, worse application.

Social Identity and Ideological Entrenchment

1. The Role of Identity

Here’s the thing: people tie their political beliefs to their identity. Challenge their ideology, and it’s like you just called their mother ugly. They’re not going to calmly reevaluate their beliefs — they’re going to dig in and tell you to go screw yourself.

In modern society, political affiliation is basically the new religion. It’s not just what you believe; it’s who you are. And if you mess with someone’s sense of self, get ready for a fight. People don’t like being told they’re wrong, even when they are — especially when they are.

2. Tribalism in Modern Contexts

Social media — that magical hellscape of endless arguments — takes our tribal instincts and turns them up to 11. Outrage gets the clicks, and clicks make money, so platforms keep feeding us more of the crap that makes us mad. And like the good little dopamine addicts we are, we eat it up.

3. Status and Morality

Here’s the kicker: ideologies come with moral superiority baked in. People align with a belief system not just to belong, but to feel righteous. It’s performative morality — virtue-signaling to the tribe. And if it means bending the truth or ignoring logic? Who cares? Logic doesn’t get likes.

Neurological and Emotional Influences

1. Emotional Dominance Over Logic

Your brain is not a temple of reason; it’s an emotional dumpster fire. When someone pokes your ideological bubble, the amygdala — your brain’s panic button — goes nuts. Meanwhile, the prefrontal cortex, where all the rational thinking is supposed to happen, just shrugs and says, “Not my problem.”

2. Cognitive Load and Mental Energy

Thinking is hard, okay? It burns calories, and our brains are lazy. When we’re stressed or tired, we fall back on what’s easy — our ideological autopilot. That’s why tired people make bad decisions, like arguing politics after three glasses of wine.

3. Mirror Neurons and Empathy Gaps

You’d think mirror neurons — those little empathy machines in your brain — would help us see things from someone else’s perspective. But nope! If they’re not in your tribe, your mirror neurons are like, “Sorry, can’t relate.” Makes it pretty damn hard to understand opposing viewpoints.

The Sociocultural Feedback Loop

1. Media Amplification

The media’s motto? “If it bleeds, it leads.” Outrage sells, and we’re all buying. Algorithm-driven platforms feed us whatever keeps us scrolling, which usually means the most divisive, clickbaity crap they can find. It’s like eating junk food for your brain — tasty but toxic.

2. Normalization of Extremes

You ever notice how what used to be extreme is now just Tuesday? That’s the Overton Window at work. Repeated exposure to ideological garbage moves the goalposts, making the crazy seem normal and the reasonable seem boring. Moderate? Ha! Nobody cares about moderate.

The Path to Liberation

So, how do we break out of this ideological prison? Good question. Let’s try not to screw it up.

1. Meta-Cognition

Step one: get your head out of your ass. Start paying attention to how you think. When you’re getting worked up over politics, ask yourself, “Am I thinking or just reacting?” Spoiler alert: it’s probably the latter.

2. Exposure to Complexity

Try listening to people you disagree with. I know, it’s painful, but it’s good for you. Complexity builds character. It’s like eating your vegetables but for your brain.

3. Institutional Interventions

Our schools need to teach critical thinking and media literacy, not just the dates of old wars no one cares about. And while we’re at it, maybe rein in those tech companies making bank off our outrage.

4. Evolved Moral Reasoning

If we can figure out how to leverage shared values, we might stand a chance. Appeal to fairness, care, or whatever makes people less likely to bite each other’s heads off. It’s not perfect, but it’s a start.

Conclusion: Beyond Impairment

The problem isn’t just that political ideology impairs reasoning; it’s that we’re too busy being self-righteous to notice. Ideologies can be useful, sure, but they’re also cages we willingly lock ourselves into. If we want to break free, we’ve got to think a little harder, listen a little more, and stop treating politics like a damn football game. Or don’t. But don’t say I didn’t warn you.

If you’re enjoying the content on my blog and would like to dive deeper into exclusive insights, I invite you to check out my Patreon page. It’s a space where you can support my work and get access to behind-the-scenes articles, in-depth analyses, and more. Your support helps me keep creating high-quality content and allows me to explore even more exciting topics. Visit [patreon.com/ChristianBaghai](https://www.patreon.com/ChristianBaghai) and join the community today! Thank you for being a part of this journey!

Christian Baghai | Patreon

Checkmate Economics: How Trump Played Checkers in a Chessboard World | Patreon

The Flimsy Bullsh*t of Modern Propaganda | Patreon

Propaganda’s Playbook: Manipulation Made Easy | Patreon

The Paradox of Propaganda: Dumb Enough to Believe, Smart Enough to Know Better | Patreon

Ukraine’s F-16 Fighter Jets: Beyond the Battlefield | Patreon

The Mind of the Machine: How Chess-Playing Computers Reveal the Behavior of Artificial Intelligence | Patreon

The Clusterf of Trump’s Rhetoric and U.S. Leadership: A Stand-Up Routine in Global Politics | Patreon

The Russian Military: A Corruption Circus That Never Leaves Town | Patreon

The Suppression of Pro-Ukraine Voices on Social Media: | Patreon

Asymmetric Carnage: When the Underdogs Play to Win | Patreon

War, Ballet, and Blunders: The Theater of Modern Conflict | Patreon