Shifting Tides in French Politics: The Turbulent Journey of Macron’s Immigration Bill

Christian Baghai
2 min readDec 20, 2023

--

The situation surrounding President Emmanuel Macron’s immigration bill in the French Parliament is a vivid illustration of the complexities and divisions within French politics. Despite initial setbacks, the bill has now been passed by a wide margin, indicating a shift in the parliamentary landscape and the influence of different political factions.

The bill’s journey through the legislative process was marked by significant opposition and internal discord within Macron’s party. Notably, the bill was initially voted down in the National Assembly without even being debated, which was a major setback for Macron’s administration. This initial rejection was a result of a coalition of lawmakers from different political backgrounds, including Marine Le Pen’s far-right Rassemblement National (RN), conservatives from Les Republicains (LR), and members of the left bloc, who joined forces against the bill.

Interior Minister Gerald Darmanin, a key figure in spearheading the legislation, faced considerable pressure and even offered his resignation following the bill’s initial rejection. However, President Macron and Prime Minister Elisabeth Borne urged Darmanin to continue and find alternative ways to advance the bill.

The bill underwent significant amendments to garner enough support for its passage. These amendments included changes in regulations on residency permits and delaying migrants’ access to welfare benefits, including for children and housing. The amendments also introduced migration quotas, made it harder for migrants’ children to become French, and proposed that dual nationals sentenced for serious crimes against the police could be stripped of their French nationality. These toughened measures won the approval of the far right, leading to the bill’s eventual passage with a vote of 349 in favor and 186 against.

Despite its eventual passage, the bill caused a rift within Macron’s party, with some members accusing the government of caving in to far-right influences. The internal rebellion within Macron’s party was significant, with some members voting against the bill or abstaining, though a majority voted in favor. Marine Le Pen hailed the bill’s passage as an “ideological victory” for her party, emphasizing the bill’s alignment with far-right immigration views.

The passage of this bill ahead of the European Parliament elections, where immigration is expected to be a key issue, demonstrates the shifting political dynamics in France. It also indicates a potential realignment of political forces within the country, as the government had to compromise and align with the far right to ensure the bill’s passage.

--

--

Christian Baghai
Christian Baghai

No responses yet