Proxy Wars: Strategic Choices in Syria and Ukraine

6 min read6 days ago

Let’s get real: proxy wars are the geopolitical version of saying, “Let’s fight, but not in my backyard.” Some are dressed up as noble missions, while others are messy, chaotic disasters. Case in point: the United States’ support for Ukraine versus Turkey’s support for Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) in Syria. Spoiler alert: one defends democracy, the other fuels the chaos machine.

Redefining Proxy Wars: Who’s Really Calling the Shots?

Proxy wars are all about power and influence, but not all are created equal. Some align with global norms, and others just blow sh*t up.

Turkey in Syria: Turkey’s proxies, like HTS, are loose cannons. HTS is a group with extremist roots that’s as reliable as a broken clock. Turkey says it wants stability, but partnering with HTS is like hiring arsonists to run a fire department. The result? Northern Syria is a patchwork of chaos, with no plan for peace.
The U.S. and Ukraine: On the flip side, Ukraine isn’t some puppet dancing to America’s tune. It’s a sovereign nation fighting off an aggressor. The U.S. gives Ukraine tools to defend its borders and democratic values. Unlike Syria’s fragmented mess, Ukraine knows what it’s fighting for — survival and sovereignty.

So, here’s the deal: in Ukraine, the U.S. backs a nation with a mission. In Syria, Turkey is stuck with allies who might turn on them tomorrow.

Why Engage? Motives That Matter

Not all proxy wars have the same endgame. Let’s break down the motives behind Turkey and America’s moves.

Turkey’s Gamble in Syria

Kurdish Containment: Turkey’s main fear? A Kurdish state at its doorstep. So, they’ve armed rebels to keep the Kurds in check. But relying on HTS? That’s like lighting a match in a room full of gas.
Regional Power Grab: Erdoğan’s Ottoman nostalgia fuels Turkey’s actions. He wants to be the big man in the Middle East, but using extremist groups undercuts any long-term credibility.
Refugee Problem: Turkey wants to shove millions of refugees back into northern Syria. The catch? Partnering with HTS makes that area anything but safe.

America’s Strategy in Ukraine

Defending Sovereignty: The U.S. is standing by the principle that borders aren’t suggestions. Ukraine’s fight isn’t just their own — it’s about stopping Russia from redrawing the world map with tanks.
Weakening a Bully: Let’s not kid ourselves: this is about keeping Russia in check without sending American troops. Smart move, right?
Strengthening Alliances: The Ukraine war has rallied NATO like a high-stakes team huddle. And guess who’s calling the plays? Uncle Sam.

Turkey’s moves in Syria are all short-term gains with long-term messes. The U.S., meanwhile, has a clearer, smarter game plan in Ukraine.

Proxy Wars: Chaos vs. Principles

In today’s world, proxy wars are about influence, but the outcomes vary wildly.

Turkey’s Mess: Relying on HTS is a ticking time bomb. They don’t follow orders, and their agenda often clashes with Turkey’s. The result? A region stuck in perpetual chaos, where civilians pay the price.
America’s Vision: The U.S. sees Ukraine as more than just a battleground. It’s a stand against authoritarianism and a way to reinforce global stability. That’s a proxy war with a purpose, not a gamble.

Turkey’s actions deepen divisions. The U.S. in Ukraine is playing a long game — and it’s working.

The Human Cost: Who’s Paying the Price?

Proxy wars aren’t just geopolitical chess matches. Real people get caught in the crossfire. Here’s the difference:

Syria’s Never-Ending Nightmare: Turkey’s support for HTS keeps Syria fractured. Millions are displaced, cities are rubble, and lawlessness rules. It’s a humanitarian black hole with no light at the end of the tunnel.
Ukraine’s Fight for Freedom: Ukraine is battered but not broken. With U.S. support, it’s fighting to rebuild and preserve its democratic identity. The cost is high, but the goal is clear: independence and stability.

One proxy war feeds despair; the other fuels resilience.

Sovereignty: One Strengthened, One Shattered

Syria and Ukraine tell two very different stories about sovereignty.

Syria’s Collapse: Turkey’s reliance on HTS has turned northern Syria into a free-for-all. Sovereignty? Forget it. HTS and other groups prioritize their own agendas over any semblance of unity.
Ukraine’s Stand: Ukraine’s sovereignty isn’t just intact — it’s the backbone of its fight. Despite needing external aid, Ukraine remains firmly in control of its destiny, a stark contrast to Syria’s fractured landscape.

Turkey’s actions undermine sovereignty. The U.S. in Ukraine strengthens it.

Conclusion: A Tale of Two Wars

Proxy wars expose the true priorities of those who back them. Turkey’s support for HTS reflects a shortsighted strategy that fuels instability and chaos. Meanwhile, U.S. support for Ukraine is a defense of sovereignty, democracy, and the global order.

The bottom line? Not all proxy wars are equal. Turkey’s actions in Syria are a dangerous gamble, while America’s engagement in Ukraine stands as a principled stand against aggression. In the end, it’s about values. And when it comes to proxy wars, those values make all the difference.

If you’re enjoying the content on my blog and would like to dive deeper into exclusive insights, I invite you to check out my Patreon page. It’s a space where you can support my work and get access to behind-the-scenes articles, in-depth analyses, and more. Your support helps me keep creating high-quality content and allows me to explore even more exciting topics. Visit [patreon.com/ChristianBaghai](https://www.patreon.com/ChristianBaghai) and join the community today! Thank you for being a part of this journey!

Christian Baghai | Patreon

The Depth of Geopolitics: Turkey’s Role in Syria and the Global Implications | Patreon

Politics as Theater: How Mathilde Panot Stole the Spotlight by Refusing to Play the Game | Patreon

Fake Populism: The Circus of Neglect and How It Leaves Us Holding the Bag | Patreon

Riff on Syrian Navy Losses | Patreon

The FOMO Scam: How TV Networks and Streaming Platforms Keep You Hooked | Patreon

Television: Your Brain’s Silent Hijacker and Society’s Clever Divider | Patreon

The Seductive Trap of Historical Analogies: A Rant on Syria and Beyond | Patreon

Syria’s Collapse: The Circus Leaves Town | Patreon

The Alarming Stupidity in Political Discourse: A Rant on Syria, and French Politics | Patreon

Why The Headlines About Ukraine Are Bullsh*t | Patreon

Macron’s Democracy Showdown: The Extremist Circus Packs Its Clowns | Patreon