Modern Torture, Administered by Spreadsheet: The Quiet Evil of ICE and the Loud Barbarism of Russia

5 min readMay 4, 2025

If you’re still looking for the line between autocracy and democracy, stop squinting. The line is gone. Both Russia’s filtration camps and America’s ICE detention centers operate on the same chilling logic: state-sanctioned cruelty streamlined through bureaucracy. One wears a balaclava. The other wears a lanyard.

This isn’t about who’s worse. It’s about how both systems are designed to disappear people in full compliance with policy manuals. Violence isn’t hidden. It’s protocol.

I. Filtration and Detention as Counterinsurgency: Repression with Branding

In Russia, filtration camps are a counterinsurgency tool dressed in Soviet hand-me-downs: loyalty checks, torture, forced relocation — all stamped with Putin’s greasy seal of legitimacy.

In the U.S., ICE detention does the same job in khakis and a press release. It’s demographic warfare with better fonts. Surveillance, indefinite confinement, and family destruction are just another day at the bureaucratic meat grinder.

Both systems weaponize suspicion, automate detention, and wash their hands with the same justification: “We’re just doing our job.”

II. From Gulag to Google Sheet: Bureaucracy as the Delivery Mechanism for Pain

Russia uses fists, wires, and starvation. The U.S. uses algorithms, private contractors, and budget codes.

ICE’s brutality is managed through risk-assessment software, detention quotas, and contracts with for-profit carceral conglomerates.
GEO Group and CoreCivic don’t beat prisoners — they outsource it to policy gaps and undertrained guards.

And when someone dies? It’s not a failure. It’s a “compliance review.” In both regimes, death is not an accident — it’s part of the cost model.

III. Children as Strategic Targets: The War on the Family Unit

Let’s be crystal clear: children are not collateral. They are leverage.

Russia forcibly adopts Ukrainian children, rewires their identity, and calls it humanitarianism.
The U.S. shredded thousands of migrant families under “zero tolerance,” then lost the receipts.

This isn’t a glitch. It’s policy-as-psychological warfare: destroy the family, destabilize the future, make the trauma intergenerational. Whether it’s Donetsk or Dilley, the message is the same: “You don’t belong, and your children will forget you.”

IV. Intelligence Gaps? Try Intelligence Designs

Let’s kill the myth of the “bad apple” once and for all.

Russia’s filtration network is too precise, too consistent, too wide to be “undisciplined.” It’s FSB-certified horror, implemented at scale.
ICE’s record isn’t a comedy of errors. It’s a database of necropolitics, with DHS memos, OIG reports, and internal audits proving that abuse is not the exception — it’s the operational baseline.

Both systems run not in darkness, but in full bureaucratic daylight, with just enough deniability to dodge prosecution and just enough cruelty to fulfill their purpose.

V. Security Has Become a Justification for State Sadism

The most terrifying evolution of modern intelligence isn’t surveillance. It’s how “security” became a hall pass for dehumanization.

“We don’t imprison you because you’re guilty. We imprison you because you make us nervous.”

That logic has metastasized. It no longer matters whether you’re a Ukrainian farmer or a Honduran mother — if you’re inconvenient to the state narrative, you become a data point in a cruelty machine.

Final Word: Bureaucratic Barbarism Doesn’t Need Guns — It Needs Clerks

Russia’s filtration camps run on beatings and forced confessions. ICE detention runs on missed medical appointments, delayed court dates, and “lost” family contact forms.

This is the new face of state brutality. It’s not jackboots and barbed wire anymore. It’s air conditioning, Excel spreadsheets, and fluorescent lighting. It’s cruelty that gets clocked in and clocked out, five days a week, with full federal benefits.

And worst of all? It’s invisible to the very systems that built it.

Essential Reading for Anyone Still Pretending This Is About “Policy”

“Biopolitics of Border Enforcement” — Security Dialogue
“The Logic of Mass Internment in Counterinsurgency” — RAND
“Russian Filtration in Ukraine: Hybrid War’s Civilian Repression Arm” — RUSI
“Carceral Geographies of U.S. Detention” — Geopolitics Journal
“Filtration Camps as Intelligence Infrastructure” — Journal of Intelligence and National Security

If you’re enjoying the content on my blog and would like to dive deeper into exclusive insights, I invite you to check out my Patreon page. It’s a space where you can support my work and get access to behind-the-scenes articles, in-depth analyses, and more. Your support helps me keep creating high-quality content and allows me to explore even more exciting topics. Visit [patreon.com/ChristianBaghai](https://www.patreon.com/ChristianBaghai) and join the community today! Thank you for being a part of this journey!

Christian Baghai | Patreon

To Understand Russian Atrocities in Ukraine, Stop Asking What and Start Asking Why the Hell This Is Their Blueprint | Patreon

💥 Vance’s “Few Miles” of Crap: A Masterclass in Cowardice Posing as Strategy | Patreon

🧠 The Gospel of “Smart Death”: Now with More Drones! | Patreon

Trump’s European Shock Troops: How MAGA 2025 Feeds Paramilitary Fascism Abroad | Patreon

🧻 Marc de Cacqueray-Valménier: A Fascist Franchise for the Emotionally Constipated | Patreon

The Grifter in the Union Jack: How Nigel Farage Sold You Out and Called It Patriotism | Patreon

The Puppet That Chose His Strings: Nigel Farage and the Great Middle Finger of Manufactured Rebellion | Patreon

Fraud? No, You’re Just Poor: How the Rich Wrote the Rules and Called It Justice | Patreon

Counter-Democracy, Inc.: How Billionaires Fked the System and Are Now Selling You the Bones** | Patreon

🧠 How to Infiltrate a Country Without Ever Leaving Your Couch | Patreon

🧠 The Sovereignty of Sense or: How We Let the Bullshit Walk Right Through the Front Door Wearing a Bowtie | Patreon