Jerusalem: A City Divided by History, Faith, and Politics

Christian Baghai
3 min readApr 5, 2024

--

Jerusalem, a vibrant tapestry woven from millennia of history, holds immense religious significance for Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Yet, this very significance lies at the heart of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, making Jerusalem’s status one of the most contentious issues in the region.

A Tangled Web of Annexations and Legal Battles

Following the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, Jordan occupied East Jerusalem and the West Bank. In 1950, Jordan formally annexed these territories, a move with limited international recognition and later deemed illegal by the international community.

The Six-Day War of 1967 marked a turning point. Israel captured East Jerusalem and subsequently extended its law and administration to the area, effectively incorporating it into Jerusalem Municipality. While Israel initially described these actions as administrative, legal rulings by the Israeli Supreme Court and the passing of the Jerusalem Law in 1980, declaring a united Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, were interpreted as an de facto annexation of East Jerusalem.

This move sparked international condemnation. The UN Security Council, through numerous resolutions, declared Israel’s claim to East Jerusalem null and void, emphasizing that acquiring territory by force violates international law. Resolution 478, in particular, condemned the Jerusalem Law and called for member states to withdraw diplomatic missions from the city.

A City Divided: The Current Reality

Despite international disapproval, Israel maintains its capital in Jerusalem and exercises control over the entire city. The international community, however, considers East Jerusalem occupied Palestinian territory. This discrepancy in recognition creates a complex situation on the ground. Palestinians view East Jerusalem as the rightful capital of a future Palestinian state, a vision endorsed by most of the international community.

The future of Jerusalem is expected to be a central issue in any negotiations between Israel and Palestine. The international consensus leans towards a two-state solution where the city’s status is determined through negotiations, acknowledging its significant religious and political value for both Israelis and Palestinians.

A City in Conflict: Recent Escalation and International Response

The situation in Jerusalem remains deeply complex and constantly evolving. Recent months have witnessed a heart-wrenching escalation in violence, particularly in the Gaza Strip. This conflict has resulted in devastating consequences — substantial casualties, damage to infrastructure, and a severe humanitarian crisis.

The international community is actively involved in addressing the crisis. Efforts to deliver aid are ongoing, but challenges remain. Reported incidents of aid workers being targeted highlight the dangers faced by those providing humanitarian assistance. International organizations are calling for increased access to deliver aid to those most in need.

Politically, there are signs of a shift. Some European nations, with Spain leading the way, are taking steps towards recognizing Palestinian statehood. This development occurs alongside discussions about future Palestinian leadership and the possibility of renewed peace talks.

The International Stance: Upholding International Law and the Two-State Solution

The international community continues to advocate for a two-state solution where East Jerusalem becomes the capital of a future Palestinian state. However, the emphasis remains on reaching a negotiated agreement on the city’s final status.

UN Security Council resolutions continue to hold sway, asserting that all measures taken by Israel to alter Jerusalem’s status are invalid. They uphold international law principles prohibiting the acquisition of territory by force and advocate for a peaceful resolution through negotiations.

Looking Ahead: A Hope for Peace in a Divided City

The situation in Jerusalem remains highly fluid, with ongoing conflict and international attention. The path to peace seems arduous, but the hope persists for a peaceful resolution that addresses the needs and aspirations of all parties involved.

This blog post offers a glimpse into the complexities surrounding Jerusalem. As the situation continues to evolve, staying informed is crucial to understanding the challenges and possibilities for peace in this deeply divided city.

--

--

Christian Baghai
Christian Baghai

No responses yet