AI’s Split Brain: Symbolic vs. Subsymbolic

6 min readDec 7, 2024

Artificial Intelligence. Two words thrown around like some messiah of progress, but let’s be honest, most people don’t even know what the hell it means. AI’s like a brain split in two — symbolic AI and subsymbolic AI. One’s the neat-freak librarian with a rulebook for every situation, and the other’s the reckless artist throwing paint on the wall and calling it genius. But guess what? Neither one’s got it all figured out.

Symbolic AI: The Control Freak

Symbolic AI — or as the nerds call it, “Good Old-Fashioned AI” (GOFAI) — is all about rules, symbols, and logic. Sounds great until you realize it’s like programming a robot to tie its shoes by first explaining quantum mechanics. Everything’s gotta be written down explicitly, like the world’s most boring instruction manual.

Core Principles:

It’s All About Rules: Symbolic AI uses symbols to represent stuff — things like “John,” “apple,” or “John eats apple.” You’ve basically got a giant flowchart for life.
Logic Overload: It’s the ultimate nerd’s dream: endless if-then statements and predicates. “If X, then Y. Unless Z, then back to X.” You get the idea.
Super Transparent: Every decision it makes is clear as day…and about as exciting as watching paint dry.

Applications:

Expert Systems: Fancy term for databases pretending to be doctors or lawyers.
Formal Logic: Great if you’re into proving theorems instead of, you know, living your life.

Limitations:

Fragile as Hell: Symbolic AI is great until the real world steps in. One hiccup in your perfect rulebook and it’s out cold.
Scalability? Nope: Try writing rules for something messy like language…good luck.
No Street Smarts: It’s like that kid in school who aces tests but has no idea how to cross the street.

Subsymbolic AI: The Wild Child

And then we have subsymbolic AI — the rebellious teenager of artificial intelligence. It doesn’t bother with rules or logic. Nah, this one learns by doing. Throw it a pile of data and it starts connecting dots like it’s solving a conspiracy theory.

Core Principles:

Patterns, Baby! Forget rules; subsymbolic AI uses neural networks to find patterns in data, even if those patterns make no sense to you or me.
It’s All About Learning: Feed it enough cat pictures and it’ll recognize your tabby. Feed it more, and it might start judging your taste in cats.
Mystery Box: How does it work? Beats me. All that intelligence is buried in a web of numbers and connections. It works, but nobody knows why.

Applications:

Image and Speech Recognition: Spotting your face or telling Alexa to shut up.
Natural Language Processing: All those chatbots pretending to care about your problems.
Autonomous Systems: Cars that drive themselves…mostly.

Limitations:

It’s a Black Box: Good luck explaining why it made a decision. It’s like asking a psychic to justify their “predictions.”
Data Hungry: If you don’t have mountains of labeled data, this thing’s as clueless as a goldfish.
Logical Dumbass: Don’t ask it to solve a riddle. It’ll just throw spaghetti at the wall and hope something sticks.

The Odd Couple: Symbolic vs. Subsymbolic

Here’s the thing: both these approaches suck on their own. Symbolic AI’s too rigid. Subsymbolic AI’s too vague. It’s like having two left shoes — useless unless you like falling on your face.

Why These Two Need Marriage Counseling

The big brains in AI realized these two approaches need to stop bickering and start working together. Enter neuro-symbolic AI: the lovechild of rules and chaos.

Why Combine Them?

Brains Meet Brawn:

Symbolic AI makes everything explainable.

Subsymbolic AI makes everything adaptable.

Smarter Learning:

Symbolic rules give subsymbolic AI a head start.

Subsymbolic systems find patterns the symbolic side misses.

Generalization:

Together, they’re like peanut butter and jelly — good for structured and unstructured problems alike.

Real-Life Magic Tricks:

Healthcare: Imagine an AI that not only analyzes X-rays but explains its diagnosis using medical guidelines.
Self-Driving Cars: Neural networks handle the messy visuals, and symbolic rules keep you from running red lights.
Language: Subsymbolic AI gets the tone right; symbolic AI makes sure it’s grammatically correct. Balance, baby.

Philosophical Rant Time

Now here’s where it gets fun: what does this tell us about intelligence? Is it all rules and logic, or is it intuition and patterns? Turns out, it’s both. Human brains do this all the time.

Recognizing your buddy’s face at a bar? That’s subsymbolic.
Deciding whether to lend him money? That’s symbolic.

If AI’s ever gonna match human intelligence, it’ll need to juggle both — like a tightrope walker with ADHD.

The Road Ahead: Neuro-Symbolic Bliss

The future isn’t about choosing between symbolic or subsymbolic AI — it’s about smashing them together into one glorious Frankenstein. Picture this:

AI That Explains Itself: It can learn like a neural network but justify its actions with symbolic rules. Accountability, baby!
Scalable Smarts: Neuro-symbolic systems can handle complexity without losing their cool.
Better Human-AI Collabs: AI that thinks like us — part logical, part intuitive — makes teamwork a breeze.

Final Thoughts: The AI Odd Couple

Symbolic AI’s like the nerd who plans every step of their day. Subsymbolic AI’s the stoner who just goes with the flow. Separately, they’re flawed, but together, they’re unstoppable. Neuro-symbolic AI is the future, combining the best of both worlds: the logic of rules and the creativity of patterns.

The question isn’t whether symbolic or subsymbolic AI will win. It’s how we’ll mix them to build something smarter than the sum of their parts. Because let’s face it: AI needs all the help it can get.

If you’re enjoying the content on my blog and would like to dive deeper into exclusive insights, I invite you to check out my Patreon page. It’s a space where you can support my work and get access to behind-the-scenes articles, in-depth analyses, and more. Your support helps me keep creating high-quality content and allows me to explore even more exciting topics. Visit [patreon.com/ChristianBaghai](https://www.patreon.com/ChristianBaghai) and join the community today! Thank you for being a part of this journey!

Christian Baghai | Patreon

Macron’s Democracy Showdown: The Extremist Circus Packs Its Clowns | Patreon

Why The Headlines About Ukraine Are Bullsh*t | Patreon

Urban Warfare and Disinformation | Patreon

China’s Rare Minerals Ban: Flexing Muscles or Fanning Flames? | Patreon

South Korea’s Political Circus: Martial Law, Impeachment, and a Defense Minister Swap — Let’s Unpack This | Patreon

The Far Right’s Hypocrisy About Free Speech | Patreon

The Evolution Beyond Mechanization: How Humanoid Robotics is (Not So Quietly) Reshaping Society | Patreon

The Future of Artificial Intelligence | Patreon

The Neuroscience of Leadership and the Art of Modern Storytelling: Lessons from Roosevelt to Today | Patreon

The Circus of Chaos: Exposing Market Shenanigans in Trump’s America | Patreon

Chaos as Strategy: How China Manipulates Global Trade for Geopolitical Dominance | Patreon